The last search I will be conducting is a Citation Pearl Database in the Library Lit Database.
During one of my previous searches I found the article:
Preservation in American Public Libraries: A Contradiction in Terms by Susan L. Tolbert
I decided to look at the subject headings and choose one to explore further.
I chose to search:
Author=tolbert
Title = preservation in american public libraries
The subject heading I chose to explore further was "Preservation of library materials."
Some of the searches returned were:
Conway, P. Tec(h)tonics: Reimagining preservation. College & Research Libraries News v. 69 no. 10 (November 2008) p. 598-601
Anderson, R. Preservation, Yes - But What Shall We Preserve?. Against the Grain v. 20 no. 5 (November 2008) p. 52, 54
Hutchins, D., et. al., The Conservation Kitchen: Basic Tools for Any Preservation Recipe. PNLA Quarterly v. 73 no. 1 (Fall 2008) p. 27
Bee, R. The Importance of Preserving Paper-Based Artifacts in a Digital Age. The Library Quarterly v. 78 no. 2 (April 2008) p. 179-94
Eggert, P. The Conservator's Gaze and the Nature of the Work. Library Trends v. 56 no. 1 (Summer 2007) p. 80-106
-------------------------------------
Reflection on Search: I really liked this search. It provided extremely relevant articles about how to conserve and preserve library, archival, and museum collections. I really liked the Preservation, Yes - But What Shall We Preserve article because it made me think about what really would be beneficial for my library to spend the time to preserve. I think I might try this searching method a lot more because it brought up extremely relevant results and narrowed the search really well.
Tuesday, March 24, 2009
Competency #6 -- Databases -- Successive Fractions
My next search will be a successive fractions search in the WorldCat database. I still want to focus on preservation and conservation in libraries, archives, and museums during natural disasters.
I felt the broadest facet would be the search archive OR library OR museum.
S1 is archive OR library OR museum and returned 7,021,068 results. These results did not surprise me though because all terms in this facet are extremely broad.
S1 AND preservation OR conservation returned 351,559 results. These results still did not surprise me though because I had not narrowed down to the specific area I am interested in.
S2 AND natural disaster OR emergency OR catastrophe returned 625 results. These results were a little more manageable compares with the other numbers. I still wanted to narrow it down a little more and chose to add a few limiters.
I limited S3 to the language English, material type Books, and Years 1995-2009. This returned 135 results. A few of the results were:
Preservation : issues and planning /
Author: Banks, Paul N.; Pilette, Roberta.
Publication: Chicago : American Library Association, 2000
Protecting your library's digital sources : the essential guide to planning and preservation /
Author: Kahn, Miriam
Publication: Chicago : American Library Association, 2004
Preserving library materials : a manual /
Author: Swartzburg, Susan G., 1938-
Publication: Metuchen, N.J. : Scarecrow Press, 1995
An ounce of prevention : integrated disaster planning for archives, libraries, and record centres /
Author: Wellheiser, Johanna G.; Scott, Jude,
Publication: Lanham, Md. : Scarecrow Press ; Toronto, Ont. : Canadian Archives Foundation, 2002
Disaster management for libraries and archives /
Author: Matthews, Graham,; Feather, John.
Publication: Aldershot, Hampshire, England ; Burlington, VT : Ashgate Pub., 2003
-------------------------------------
Reflection on Search: I was pleasantly surprised with the amount of relevant results so close to the top. I found several items that I am going to try and get my hands on for further examination. I like this search method because it lets you look at what comes up as you add each additional facet to the search string. This was helpful in finding additional resources that might be filtered out when you add the next facet or buried further down in the results.
I felt the broadest facet would be the search archive OR library OR museum.
S1 is archive OR library OR museum and returned 7,021,068 results. These results did not surprise me though because all terms in this facet are extremely broad.
S1 AND preservation OR conservation returned 351,559 results. These results still did not surprise me though because I had not narrowed down to the specific area I am interested in.
S2 AND natural disaster OR emergency OR catastrophe returned 625 results. These results were a little more manageable compares with the other numbers. I still wanted to narrow it down a little more and chose to add a few limiters.
I limited S3 to the language English, material type Books, and Years 1995-2009. This returned 135 results. A few of the results were:
Preservation : issues and planning /
Author: Banks, Paul N.; Pilette, Roberta.
Publication: Chicago : American Library Association, 2000
Protecting your library's digital sources : the essential guide to planning and preservation /
Author: Kahn, Miriam
Publication: Chicago : American Library Association, 2004
Preserving library materials : a manual /
Author: Swartzburg, Susan G., 1938-
Publication: Metuchen, N.J. : Scarecrow Press, 1995
An ounce of prevention : integrated disaster planning for archives, libraries, and record centres /
Author: Wellheiser, Johanna G.; Scott, Jude,
Publication: Lanham, Md. : Scarecrow Press ; Toronto, Ont. : Canadian Archives Foundation, 2002
Disaster management for libraries and archives /
Author: Matthews, Graham,; Feather, John.
Publication: Aldershot, Hampshire, England ; Burlington, VT : Ashgate Pub., 2003
-------------------------------------
Reflection on Search: I was pleasantly surprised with the amount of relevant results so close to the top. I found several items that I am going to try and get my hands on for further examination. I like this search method because it lets you look at what comes up as you add each additional facet to the search string. This was helpful in finding additional resources that might be filtered out when you add the next facet or buried further down in the results.
Monday, March 23, 2009
Competency #6 -- Databases -- Specific Facet First Search
I next decided to complete a specific facet search in ERIC/Ebscohost. I did not think it would be very successful given the generic nature of each set of search strings independent of each other.
The preservation set gave me 12903 results.
The archive set gave me 63216 results.
The natural disaster set gave me 5061 results.
I looked at the natural disaster set since it was the smallest and at first glance it had nothing to do with what I wanted to research. It did provide interesting information though. I particularly liked the results:
How Disasters Affect Local Labor Markets: The Effects of Hurricanes in Florida
By: Belasen, Ariel R.; Polachek, Solomon W.. Journal of Human Resources, v44 n1 p251-276 Win 2009
Community Preparedness
By: Randazzo, Dante. Community College Journal, v79 n3 p28-30, 32-33 Dec 2008-Jan 2009
While the results did not have anything to do with libraries it did provide general information of which some could be applied to preparing for a natural disaster.
I decided to go back and perform a standard building block search.
When I completed a standard building block search I received 63 results.
I particularly liked:
Preservation in the Digital Age: What Is To Be Done?
By: Smith, Abby. American Libraries, v30 n3 p36-39 Mar 1999
Disaster Response Plan, Cunningham Memorial Library, Indiana State University
By: Gaul, Kathleen. 1998 24 pp
Disaster Response and Planning for Libraries
By: Kahn, Miriam B.. 1998 184 pp.
Preservation in American Public Libraries: A Contradiction in Terms?
By: Tolbert, Susan L.. Public Libraries, v36 n4 p236-45 Jul-Aug 1997
Preparing for Library Emergencies: A Cooperative Approach
By: Davis, Mary B.; And Others. Wilson Library Bulletin, v66 n3 p42-44,128 Nov 1991
-------------------------------------
Reflection on Search: I knew when I started this search it would not bring many specific results since each of my facets were so generic. The facets had meaning when I combined them together by completing a standard building block search. Again I did receive good general information about preparing for a disaster and what communities or cities do to prepare their material and equipment. I also did receive great results when I completed the standard building block search. I again found great subject headings that could be used later to complete a citation pearl search.
The preservation set gave me 12903 results.
The archive set gave me 63216 results.
The natural disaster set gave me 5061 results.
I looked at the natural disaster set since it was the smallest and at first glance it had nothing to do with what I wanted to research. It did provide interesting information though. I particularly liked the results:
How Disasters Affect Local Labor Markets: The Effects of Hurricanes in Florida
By: Belasen, Ariel R.; Polachek, Solomon W.. Journal of Human Resources, v44 n1 p251-276 Win 2009
Community Preparedness
By: Randazzo, Dante. Community College Journal, v79 n3 p28-30, 32-33 Dec 2008-Jan 2009
While the results did not have anything to do with libraries it did provide general information of which some could be applied to preparing for a natural disaster.
I decided to go back and perform a standard building block search.
When I completed a standard building block search I received 63 results.
I particularly liked:
Preservation in the Digital Age: What Is To Be Done?
By: Smith, Abby. American Libraries, v30 n3 p36-39 Mar 1999
Disaster Response Plan, Cunningham Memorial Library, Indiana State University
By: Gaul, Kathleen. 1998 24 pp
Disaster Response and Planning for Libraries
By: Kahn, Miriam B.. 1998 184 pp.
Preservation in American Public Libraries: A Contradiction in Terms?
By: Tolbert, Susan L.. Public Libraries, v36 n4 p236-45 Jul-Aug 1997
Preparing for Library Emergencies: A Cooperative Approach
By: Davis, Mary B.; And Others. Wilson Library Bulletin, v66 n3 p42-44,128 Nov 1991
-------------------------------------
Reflection on Search: I knew when I started this search it would not bring many specific results since each of my facets were so generic. The facets had meaning when I combined them together by completing a standard building block search. Again I did receive good general information about preparing for a disaster and what communities or cities do to prepare their material and equipment. I also did receive great results when I completed the standard building block search. I again found great subject headings that could be used later to complete a citation pearl search.
Competency #6 -- Databases -- Building Block Search
I chose to start with a building block search in Academic Search Complete. I wanted to focus on preservation and conservation in an archive, library, and museum setting during a natural disaster.
My different facets are:
Here are my searches:
preservation OR conservation = s1
archive OR library OR museum = s2
natural disaster OR emergency OR catastrophe = s3
s1 AND s2 AND s3 = 92
Here are a few hits I received from the search:
Repairing Art Damaged By Natural Disasters.
By: Henning, Joel. Wall Street Journal - Eastern Edition, 8/12/2008, Vol. 252 Issue 36, pD7, 0p, 1 bw
Protecting Treasures On A Shaky Planet
By: Kino, Carol. New York Times, 03/12/2008, p18, 0p
Disaster Planning in Libraries.
By: Yi Ling Wong; Green, Ravonne. Journal of Access Services, 2006, Vol. 4 Issue 3/4, p71-82, 12p
Coming Back From Major Disaster: Month One
By: Curzon, Susan Carol. Public Library Quarterly, 2006, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p17-29, 13p
The Seven Deadly Sins of Disaster Recovery
By: Silverman, Randy. Public Library Quarterly, 2006, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p31-46, 16p
-------------------------------------
Reflection on Search: I had tried using truncation (*) on several of my search terms to include plural and alternative spellings but doing this brought up way too irrelevant results. I chose not to truncate in order to get a more manageable set of search results and more relevant results. I was happy overall with the results although the terms did trigger some medical results since several journals start with Archives in or Archives of. I did find several subject headings that I would like to complete a Citation Pearl or Snowballing Approach search with.
My different facets are:
- Preservation, archives, natural disaster
- Preservation, conservation
- Archive, library, museum
- Natural disaster, emergency, catastrophe
Here are my searches:
preservation OR conservation = s1
archive OR library OR museum = s2
natural disaster OR emergency OR catastrophe = s3
s1 AND s2 AND s3 = 92
Here are a few hits I received from the search:
Repairing Art Damaged By Natural Disasters.
By: Henning, Joel. Wall Street Journal - Eastern Edition, 8/12/2008, Vol. 252 Issue 36, pD7, 0p, 1 bw
Protecting Treasures On A Shaky Planet
By: Kino, Carol. New York Times, 03/12/2008, p18, 0p
Disaster Planning in Libraries.
By: Yi Ling Wong; Green, Ravonne. Journal of Access Services, 2006, Vol. 4 Issue 3/4, p71-82, 12p
Coming Back From Major Disaster: Month One
By: Curzon, Susan Carol. Public Library Quarterly, 2006, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p17-29, 13p
The Seven Deadly Sins of Disaster Recovery
By: Silverman, Randy. Public Library Quarterly, 2006, Vol. 25 Issue 3/4, p31-46, 16p
-------------------------------------
Reflection on Search: I had tried using truncation (*) on several of my search terms to include plural and alternative spellings but doing this brought up way too irrelevant results. I chose not to truncate in order to get a more manageable set of search results and more relevant results. I was happy overall with the results although the terms did trigger some medical results since several journals start with Archives in or Archives of. I did find several subject headings that I would like to complete a Citation Pearl or Snowballing Approach search with.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)